中文
 

Follow us 

Hot Topic
Market News
Events & Promo
Career Tips
Education News
Health & Life
Chief Justice Sundaresh Menon Highlights the Importance of Human Judgment in the Age of Artificial Intelligence
PRNewswire

Chief Justice Sundaresh Menon Highlights the Importance of Human Judgment in the Age of Artificial Intelligence

Publish date: 30 Oct 2026

Follow us

Stay updated on the job market

Popular Articles

【天氣轉涼】天文台:今晚急跌明早最低16度!新界溫差極大,打工仔出門必備「洋蔥式著法」
【天氣轉涼】天文台:今晚急跌明早最低16度!新界溫差極大,打工仔出門必備「洋蔥式著法」
【辦公室職業病】Office 工最易中嘅四大職場傷患!入嚟睇吓你有無中招(附預防自救法)
【辦公室職業病】Office 工最易中嘅四大職場傷患!入嚟睇吓你有無中招(附預防自救法)
【AI 衝擊打工仔】最新調查:逾半港人憂AI令退休前景更難預測!「飯碗不保」恐打破傳統退養規劃
【AI 衝擊打工仔】最新調查:逾半港人憂AI令退休前景更難預測!「飯碗不保」恐打破傳統退養規劃
【薪酬趨勢調查】本港僱員今年平均加薪 2.3%!預測明年升至 3.1%,增幅仍遜大灣區內地城市
【薪酬趨勢調查】本港僱員今年平均加薪 2.3%!預測明年升至 3.1%,增幅仍遜大灣區內地城市
【鐵飯碗神話幻滅?】護理畢業即失業!寄成百封 CV 零回音,香港護士正面臨大洗牌
【鐵飯碗神話幻滅?】護理畢業即失業!寄成百封 CV 零回音,香港護士正面臨大洗牌

SINGAPORE, Oct. 30, 2026 /PRNewswire/ -- The Honourable the Chief Justice Sundaresh Menon of the Supreme Court of Singapore observed that while Artificial Intelligence (AI) offers significant opportunities to improve access to justice and judicial efficiency, human judgment must remain central to the administration of justice. Delivering his speech titled "AI and the Judicial Function: The Limits of Artificial Judgment" at the 28th Annual Australian Judicial Officers Association Colloquium 2026 on 9 October in Brisbane, Australia, Chief Justice Menon noted that AI has already entered the justice system through the parties, the profession and the tools used to administer our Courts.

Chief Justice Sundaresh Menon delivering his speech at the Australian Judicial Officers Association Colloquium 2026 in Brisbane, Australia.
Chief Justice Sundaresh Menon delivering his speech at the Australian Judicial Officers Association Colloquium 2026 in Brisbane, Australia.

In his speech, Chief Justice Menon posed the question of how far judges should engage with AI, for what purposes, and on what terms. He suggested that AI's role in adjudication should be calibrated to the nature of the judicial function involved — the closer AI comes to exercising judgment, the greater the need for restraint.

He grounded his analysis in three requirements of sound adjudication: judicial integrity, procedural fairness, and institutional effectiveness. Much of the case for the judicial application of AI is about institutional effectiveness. The attraction of AI lies in its scale, its speed and its baseline reliability, seemingly enabling courts to serve more users, more quickly, while continuing to produce outcomes that are generally correct. But effectiveness alone cannot justify every use.

To examine the role AI might play within the adjudicative process, Chief Justice Menon suggested disaggregating the composite activity of adjudication into its working parts, so as to distil the values engaged by each part of the process and the trade-offs that attend different uses of AI. In his view, the case for AI is most compelling where it is used to acquire information, more qualified where AI analyses that material or proposes outcomes, and most limited where it formulates judicial reasons.

Beyond identifying the uses of AI that may be acceptable in principle, Chief Justice Menon stressed that practical questions of design and governance were no less important. He cautioned that a sound use of AI can be rendered unsafe by the design of the tool, the structure of the workflow or the habits of the user. In particular, he drew attention to three risks of human-machine collaboration: over-reliance, skills fade and hidden institutional delegation. The answer to these risks was not to retreat from AI, but to govern its use in ways that preserve meaningful human judgment and control, and he offered five observations on what this might entail in practice.

Chief Justice Menon concluded with the observation that while AI may seem highly intelligent, it is inescapably artificial. It cannot bear judicial responsibility, nor replicate the human encounter at the heart of a fair hearing. In adjudication, being human is not a deficiency to be minimised. In many ways, it is precisely the point.

Visit Chief Justice Sundaresh Menon: Speech at the Australian Judicial Officers Association Colloquium 2026 for more details.

Follow us

Stay updated on the job market

Popular Articles

【天氣轉涼】天文台:今晚急跌明早最低16度!新界溫差極大,打工仔出門必備「洋蔥式著法」
【天氣轉涼】天文台:今晚急跌明早最低16度!新界溫差極大,打工仔出門必備「洋蔥式著法」
【辦公室職業病】Office 工最易中嘅四大職場傷患!入嚟睇吓你有無中招(附預防自救法)
【辦公室職業病】Office 工最易中嘅四大職場傷患!入嚟睇吓你有無中招(附預防自救法)
【AI 衝擊打工仔】最新調查:逾半港人憂AI令退休前景更難預測!「飯碗不保」恐打破傳統退養規劃
【AI 衝擊打工仔】最新調查:逾半港人憂AI令退休前景更難預測!「飯碗不保」恐打破傳統退養規劃
【薪酬趨勢調查】本港僱員今年平均加薪 2.3%!預測明年升至 3.1%,增幅仍遜大灣區內地城市
【薪酬趨勢調查】本港僱員今年平均加薪 2.3%!預測明年升至 3.1%,增幅仍遜大灣區內地城市
【鐵飯碗神話幻滅?】護理畢業即失業!寄成百封 CV 零回音,香港護士正面臨大洗牌
【鐵飯碗神話幻滅?】護理畢業即失業!寄成百封 CV 零回音,香港護士正面臨大洗牌

Hottest Tags

#天文台天氣
#香港轉涼
#最低16度
#新界清涼
#日夜溫差
#東北季候風
#九天天氣預報
#香港氣溫
#保暖穿搭
#秋冬季天氣
#辦公室職業病
#打工仔勞損

Contact Us
Notice
Back to Top
We use cookies to enhance your experience on our website. Please read and confirm your agreement to our Privacy Policy and Terms and Conditions before continue to browse our website. Read and Agreed